Holiday Retargeting Best Practices

03/09/2025

E-commerce / Marketing Strategy

Holiday shoppers may browse and leave, but the right retargeting strategies can bring them back—here’s how to optimize your holiday retargeting campaigns for maximum impact.

Abstract graphic featuring a stylized Christmas tree in the center of a circular blue and black design, with scattered dots resembling snow or festive confetti.

Alright, fellow ecommerce rockstars! As the holiday season gears up and the shopping arenas light up, there's that one riff we can't afford to miss: retargeting. Think of it as the comeback tour for your products. You know, that encore performance for the almost-converted fans who left your gig (or cart) a tad too early. During the festive crescendo, every shopper's screen is like a festival stage, crowded with brands vying for the spotlight. And in this digital mosh pit, retargeting is your backstage pass, your golden ticket to steal the show. But here's the kicker: it's not just about being loud; it's about hitting the right notes at the right time. Ready to master the art of the holiday retarget? To craft campaigns that don't just echo but resonate? Lace up those boots, grab that mic, and let’s dive deep into the world of holiday retargeting best practices. Encore, anyone?

Sloane Avery
Play IconPause Icon
0:00
0:00

Why Retargeting is Crucial During the Holiday

Lightbox sign reading “CYBER MONDAY #SALE” next to a red alarm clock on a dark background, emphasizing urgency and promotions.
Young man in traditional striped African attire standing in an elevator, looking at his smartphone with a reflection visible behind him.
Hands holding a smartphone displaying a five-star rating, symbolizing excellent customer service or product satisfaction.
No items found.

Alright, let's set the stage.

As the holiday symphony plays on, every brand's trying to belt out their own solo.

But here's the thing: amidst the cacophony of holiday deals, jingles, and banners, a significant chunk of the crowd gets dazzled, drifts away, and – horror of horrors – forgets about their almost-purchases.

Let’s break down why, in this grand festive concert, retargeting is the headliner:

  • Heightened Competition: Think of the holiday market as the ultimate battle of the bands. Everyone's upping their game, bringing their A-game solos, and trying to woo the crowd. In this scenario, retargeting is your brand's signature riff, helping you stand out and be remembered.
  • Fickle Consumer Behavior: We've all been there, right? Mid-gig, can't decide between the nachos or the fries. Holiday shoppers often juggle between choices, and retargeting serves as that nifty reminder, a gentle nudge towards the fries (or was it the nachos?).
  • Maximizing Advertising ROI: You've set the stage, got the lights, the sound, and even that fog machine. Now, it's all about ensuring the crowd turns up. With retargeting, you capitalize on your initial advertising efforts, making sure those who showed interest come back for the main event.

The gist?

Retargeting isn't just another item on your marketing setlist; it's the show-stopping number that can make or break your holiday sales performance.

Common Pitfalls in Holiday Retargeting

Smartphone screen showing a 25% off promotion code with a “BUY NOW” button next to a small cosmetic tube and green leaves on a white surface.
Group of people analyzing business charts and graphs on printed documents spread across a wooden desk, with pens, sticky notes, and a tablet.
Man using a laptop and desktop computer simultaneously to compare features on a website, indicating research or decision-making.
Person browsing a fashion website on a laptop showing “30% OFF DRESSES” with options for online shopping and categories like dresses and shoes.

Even the best rock legends have had their off days, hitting a wrong note or two. When it comes to the jam session of holiday retargeting, there are potential pitfalls lurking, ready to throw you off your groove.

Here's a look at some common missteps and how to dodge them like a pro:

  • Overexposure: Picture this: you've got a killer track, but it's played on loop every. single. time. Soon enough, fans are plugging their ears. In retargeting, this is the risk of overwhelming your audience with the same ad. Diversify and time your ads to avoid ad fatigue.
  • Generic Messaging: Imagine going to a concert, expecting a personalized shoutout, and getting... nada. Ouch. In retargeting, sending out generic messages misses the mark. Tailor your content for segments of your audience for that personal touch.
  • Neglecting Mobile Users: It's like planning an epic concert but forgetting about the fans in the balcony seats. In today's digital age, mobile users are a massive part of your audience. Ensure your retargeting strategies are optimized for these on-the-go rockstars.

Navigating the holiday retargeting arena is like planning a flawless concert tour.

Know the potential pitfalls, prepare for them, and you're all set to give a performance that'll have encores demanding more.

Want to learn more about brand platforms, Brand Strategy and Brand Identity? Keep reading!

If you need help with your companies brand strategy and identity, contact us for a free custom quote.

Best Practices for Effective Retargeting

Hands holding a credit card and pointing at a laptop screen displaying a bold red “SALE” banner with “Limited Time Offer” and a yellow “Start Shopping” button, set against a festive background with Christmas gift bags.

Okay, maestros of marketing, time to fine-tune our instruments and perfect our performance. The holiday stage is set, and with the right retargeting practices, you're poised to deliver a chart-topping act.

Here's your backstage pass to effective retargeting:

  • Segmentation and Personalization: Know your crowd. From the die-hard groupies to the casual listeners, segment your audience and tailor your messages. It's like dedicating a song to different fan groups, making each one feel special.
  • Frequency Capping: Ever been to a gig where the band plays the same song thrice? Don't be that band. Limit the number of times a user sees your ad to avoid overkill.
  • Dynamic Retargeting: This is like updating your setlist in real-time based on the crowd's mood. Show ads based on the actual products or services a user expressed interest in for maximum relevance.
  • Multichannel Approach: Don't just play the main stage; go acoustic, try the side stages, engage with pop-ups. In other words, retarget across various platforms and devices for comprehensive coverage.
  • Urgency and Exclusive Offers: Drop that limited-time offer or flash sale, creating a buzz similar to announcing a surprise encore. A sense of urgency can push potential buyers to act quickly.

Retargeting is more than just a follow-up act; it's the encore performance that can steal the show. With these best practices in your back pocket, you're all set to keep the holiday crowd engaged and cheering for more.

Tools and Platforms for Superior Retargeting

Excited young woman pointing at something in a store while a surprised man stands behind her, suggesting a great deal or unexpected discovery.

Alright, gearheads and digital virtuosos, it's tech time. Just as every rockstar has their favorite axe, every marketer needs their trusted toolkit. In the dazzling world of retargeting, having the right equipment can mean the difference between a sold-out show and an empty venue.

Let's explore the tech superstars that can amplify your retargeting gig:

  • Retargeting Ad Platforms: Platforms like the Google Display Network and Facebook Pixel are the big arenas where major acts play. They offer expansive reach and detailed targeting options. Know their strengths, their crowd pull, and tailor your strategies accordingly.
  • Analytics and Insights: Tools like Google Analytics are your soundchecks. They give you a sense of what's working, what's not, and where you need to tweak the acoustics. Dive deep, analyze, and refine for that perfect pitch.
  • A/B Testing Tools: Consider these your rehearsal sessions. Platforms like Optimizely or VWO allow you to test variations of your retargeting ads, ensuring you hit the stage with your best performance.
  • Automation Platforms: Tools like AdRoll or Criteo can automate your retargeting campaigns, ensuring you're always in tune, even when you're not actively managing every chord.

Retargeting, like any epic concert, requires precision, practice, and a bit of panache. With these tools in your lineup, you're ready to not just play, but to resonate, reverberate, and leave a mark that echoes long after the holidays fade.

Future-Proofing: Retargeting Trends to Watch:

Gather round, trendspotters and forward-thinkers. The world of retargeting, much like music genres, is ever-evolving. While the classic riffs remain timeless, there's always a new beat, a fresh style emerging on the horizon.

As we ride the waves of the current holiday season, let's also cast an eye to the future, tuning into the upcoming trends that promise to redefine retargeting:

  • AI and Machine Learning: Automation's next big gig. Think of it as your backstage tech wizard, predicting consumer behaviors, fine-tuning ad deliveries, and ensuring every note hits just right.
  • Video Retargeting: Static banners are great, but motion captures attention. Video retargeting is like adding a killer solo to your track, engaging and re-engaging audiences with dynamic content.
  • Privacy Concerns and Regulations: With changing data privacy laws, retargeting might feel like playing with a constantly detuning guitar. Staying updated and compliant will be key, ensuring your brand hits the right notes without stepping on any toes.
  • Interactive Retargeting: Beyond just watching or viewing, this is about getting the audience involved. Think immersive ads, augmented reality experiences, or even gamified content.
  • Cross-Device Retargeting: Consumers are hopping between devices like fans at a multi-stage festival. Ensuring a seamless retargeting experience, no matter the device, will be the name of the game.

Retargeting is more than just a current strategy; it's an ongoing concert, with new acts, evolving genres, and ever-changing stages.

Staying in tune with the latest trends ensures that your brand doesn't just play today but continues to rock the charts season after season.

Conclusion:

And there we have it, marketing maestros – a whirlwind tour of the dazzling world of holiday retargeting. From understanding its rhythm to jamming with the best tools, and drawing inspiration from the legends who've rocked this stage before, we've covered the notes, the beats, and the crescendos.

But remember, in the dynamic concert of ecommerce, retargeting isn't just a one-off gig. It's a continuous engagement, a series of encores, a commitment to keep the crowd – your audience – hooked and humming along.

So, as the holiday lights shimmer and the digital stage awaits, ask yourself: Are you ready to play, to resonate, to make your brand's presence felt in the grand symphony of sales? With the right strategies, tools, and a touch of flair, here's to ensuring every missed note becomes a future hit, and every fan keeps coming back for more.

Checkout our blog post on Tackling Abandoned Carts During the Festive Frenzy

An image of the author Sloane Avery

Sloane Avery

As entrepreneurs, they’ve built and scaled their own ventures from zero to millions. They’ve been in the trenches, navigating the chaos of high-growth phases, making the hard calls, and learning firsthand what actually moves the needle. That’s what makes us different—we don’t just “consult,” we know what it takes because we’ve done it ourselves.

Read More

Want to learn more about brand platform?

If you need help with your companies brand strategy and identity, contact us for a free custom quote.

We do great work. And get great results.

DrTung’s
Breathed new life into a storied oral care brand with a smarter site and marketing for scalable growth.

+2.3x
Increase in revenue YoY

+126%
Increase in repurchase rate YoY

READ MORE
Smiling man with bright teeth on a light blue background, surrounded by floating DrTung’s herbal tooth powder tabs and packaging.
Smartphone on a textured blue surface displaying a DrTung’s ad with the text “Make the Switch” and an image of a woman holding herbal tooth powder tabs.
Flat lay of DrTung’s oral care products, including floss, tooth powder tabs, perio sticks, tongue cleaners, and toothbrushes, arranged with a blue pouch on white tile.
Pattern of DrTung’s Activated Charcoal Floss in brown and blue packaging, arranged diagonally on a bright blue background.
Smiling man with bright teeth on a light blue background, surrounded by floating DrTung’s herbal tooth powder tabs and packaging.
Smartphone on a textured blue surface displaying a DrTung’s ad with the text “Make the Switch” and an image of a woman holding herbal tooth powder tabs.
Flat lay of DrTung’s oral care products, including floss, tooth powder tabs, perio sticks, tongue cleaners, and toothbrushes, arranged with a blue pouch on white tile.
Pattern of DrTung’s Activated Charcoal Floss in brown and blue packaging, arranged diagonally on a bright blue background.
Mary Louise Cosmetics
Scaled a heritage-inspired clean beauty brand with modern performance marketing and farm-to-face storytelling.

+93%
Revenue growth in first 90 days

+144%
Increase in attributed revenue

READ MORE
A jar of Mary Louise Lilac & Shea Body Butter with the lid open, showing creamy texture, placed on a beige surface beside sprigs of lavender.
A Mary Louise Miracle Serum bottle with a dropper cap, lying on a bed of small yellow flowers.
Mary Louise promotional print materials featuring the body butter, with images of skincare application and product photography on a textured beige background.
A close-up overhead view of multiple Mary Louise Miracle Serum bottles with yellow dropper caps arranged tightly together.
A jar of Mary Louise Lilac & Shea Body Butter with the lid open, showing creamy texture, placed on a beige surface beside sprigs of lavender.
A Mary Louise Miracle Serum bottle with a dropper cap, lying on a bed of small yellow flowers.
Mary Louise promotional print materials featuring the body butter, with images of skincare application and product photography on a textured beige background.
A close-up overhead view of multiple Mary Louise Miracle Serum bottles with yellow dropper caps arranged tightly together.
Eyecart
Made eye care feel modern, then marketed it like a DTC darling—with the results to match.

+91%
Increase in conversion rate

+46%
Increase in AOV

READ MORE
A smiling woman holds a magnifying lens with the word "eyecart" printed on it over her eye, creating a playful optical effect against a mint green background.
A billboard ad reads “Discover the ease of keeping your eyes healthy,” featuring Eyecart branding and Blephaclean eye care wipes packaging.
Multiple laptop screens display the Eyecart website, showcasing product pages and banners promoting eye care items.
A person walks past large Eyecart posters on a city wall, featuring product photography of eye care serums and creams with clean, modern branding.
A smiling woman holds a magnifying lens with the word "eyecart" printed on it over her eye, creating a playful optical effect against a mint green background.
A billboard ad reads “Discover the ease of keeping your eyes healthy,” featuring Eyecart branding and Blephaclean eye care wipes packaging.
Multiple laptop screens display the Eyecart website, showcasing product pages and banners promoting eye care items.
A person walks past large Eyecart posters on a city wall, featuring product photography of eye care serums and creams with clean, modern branding.
Lucky Girl Rosé
We turned a zero-carb rosé into a lifestyle brand that makes every moment worth celebrating.

+200%
Increase in conversion rate

+688%
Increase in attributed revenue

READ MORE
A bottle of Lucky Girl rosé wine nestled among pink and white flowers in a rustic outdoor setting.
Lucky Girl rosé wine on a red-and-white checkered picnic blanket with cherries, strawberries, sunglasses, and a pink notebook titled The Lucky Club.
A wine glass filled with rosé on a gold tray surrounded by hands with red-painted nails, overlaid with the text “Pour yourself some luck.”
A bottle of Lucky Girl rosé wine with floral label design, dramatically lit against a soft pink background with a shadow cast.
A bottle of Lucky Girl rosé wine nestled among pink and white flowers in a rustic outdoor setting.
Lucky Girl rosé wine on a red-and-white checkered picnic blanket with cherries, strawberries, sunglasses, and a pink notebook titled The Lucky Club.
A wine glass filled with rosé on a gold tray surrounded by hands with red-painted nails, overlaid with the text “Pour yourself some luck.”
A bottle of Lucky Girl rosé wine with floral label design, dramatically lit against a soft pink background with a shadow cast.